Thursday, 28 August 2014

REVEALED: A Private Memo From Nana S. K. B. Asante Pointing To Flows In The Plant Breeders Bill


Nana S.K.B Asante

The Insight has managed to obtain a copy of a memo authored by Nana S.K. B. Asante, easily Ghana most experienced negotiator with transnational corporations on the Plant Breeders Bill.

The Memo was addressed to Professor F.K. A Aclotey, President and all members of the Sub-Committee of the Ghana Academy of Arts and Sciences on the Plant Breeders Bill.

Nana Asante states in very clear language that some of the state objectives of the Bill are not realizable and that it could also lead to a situation in which resources would be siphoned out of the country.

He wrote in the circumstances, the confidence and sanguine assertion that the “Bills will encourage foreign breeders and local breeders to contribute to the development of the agricultural sector, resulting in technology  transfer and know-how as new variety enter the trade channels” is with great respect, a piece of wishful thinking….
 The full text of the memo is published below;
   4th February, 2014.

Professor F.K.A Allotey
Cc: Members of Subcommittee on Ghana Plant Breeders Bill

Dear Mr President and colleague members of the subcommittee,

I must first, apologize for my inability to attend the meetings of the subcommittee due to my indisposition.

I have read the report of the Sub Committee which broadly approves of the main substance of the Plant Breeders Bill. I note with satisfaction that apart from evaluating the scientific merits, considerable attention was paid to the intellectual property aspects of the Bill. While I am not competent to pronounce on the scientific aspects of the matter, I do have some comments on the IP implications of the Bill. My comments are informed by my long professional involvement in the relations between transnational corporations (TNCs) and developing countries, the claims of TNCs about the benign and beneficial impact of the operation of IP rights in the industrial sector on development and my experience of the operation of the legal regime for the transfer of technology in the country and in a number of other developing countries. I recently undertook a project towards the revision of Ghana’s Technology Transfer Regulations. The results were by no means reassuring.

An analysis of the Bill should be preceded by an examination of the Memorandum of the Bill, which elaborates the rationale for the proposed legislation and the benefits that would accrue from the implementation of the Act. The memorandum claims inter alia that:

“Variety Protection is particularly relevant at this time when plant breeders are being encouraged to increase their contribution to the development of agriculture in the country and the seed supply system. The protection of plant breeder rights is currently required to support plant breeding activities realized by the private and public breeding activities. Currently, arable land and other

resources needed for agricultural production worldwide are scarce. In view of the potential for productivity growth in Ghana, the provision of better seeds to farmers will result in increased yields on the same piece of land which will thereby enhance the economic development of the country. It is therefore critical that the country creates and promotes an enabling environment for the stakeholders in the agricultural sector especially the seed industry through the development of policies and strategies to ensure food security and increase the efforts of the country on international markets. Food security can be improved by breeding and making available to farmers seeds of high yielding varieties that are not only adaptable to our environment but have good taste and nutritional qualities.

The Bill will encourage foreign breeders and local breeders to contribute to the development of the agriculture sector of the economy, resulting in technology transfer and know how, as new varieties enter the channels of trade.

The Bill seeks to promote agriculture which will complement the committed initiative of the Ministry of Food and Agriculture in the development of the seed industry, as well as on going reforms in the agriculture sector. The Ministry of Justice is responsible for the administration and implementation of intellectual property rights under TRIPS and invariably has a joint responsibility with the Ministry of Trade which is entrusted with the responsibility to comply with Ghana’s international obligations under TRIPS. The emerging consensus among stakeholders indicates that variety protection can produce benefits by increasing the scope of plant improvement and help farmers to break out of the cycle of subsistence farming.”

The notion that the mere fact of protecting IP rights will increase plants breeder’s contribution to the development of agriculture should be treated with considerable skepticism, if the experience industry is evaluated. No significant contribution to industry has resulted from the bare fact of intellectual property protection. Such protection assures exclusive ownership and use to the registered owners, unless the rights are assigned or licensed to entities. The process of such transfer is riddled with conditions and restrictions which make the so called transfer largely illusory. The concern expressed by developing countries over this process were so grave that

they prevailed on UNCTAD to initiate a negotiation of an international code of conduct to regulate transfer of technology some 20 years ago. In the result TNCs of the industrialized world blocked the negotiation which aborted the Code. My own research into the technology transfer agreement such as licensed agreements, know-how agreement and technical assistance in Ghana disclose that these have proved to be notorious devices for transferring non taxable royalties and other fees from Ghana, without any meaningful transfer of technology to indigenous Ghanaian entities.

In the circumstances, the confident and sanguine assertion that the “ Bill will encourage foreign breeders and local breeders to contribute to the development of the agricultural sector, resulting in technology transfer and know-how as new variety enter the channels of trade” is, with great respect, a piece of wishful thinking. It is an illusory expectation bereft of any empirical evidence. If the Ministry of Agriculture has any empirical evidence of such technology transfer from any developing country, it should display it. Apart from the general observation, let us consider some of the practical implications of the provisions of the registration of foreign IP rights in Ghana in this sector.

According to section 9 of the Bill, virtually any foreign entity or person may apply for registration of a variety of seed in Ghana. The only requirement is that such a foreigner must come from a country with which Ghana has a treaty relationship, whatever the treaty may be. This means that all UN member countries qualify. A foreign entity or person need not be present or operate in Ghana before registration. It can appoint an agent to do so in Ghana on its behalf. It can therefore protect its rights in Ghana without the slightest intention to invest in Ghana or to transfer its technology relating to variety in Ghana. If the experience in industrial technology transfer is any guide, such transfer agreement, if it does take place, will be subject to payment of royalty and numerous restrictions. For example, any refinement of the variety by Ghanaian farmers could be prohibited or appropriated by the foreigner. The owner could also limit the geographical area of operation. An entity in Mongolia or Vancouver could dictate the operation of Ghanaian farmers.

Another practical issue is the registration process.

Foreign companies, with their vast resources, are likely to complete registration of a variety even if Ghanaian scientist has a similar variety, by virtue of the expeditious delivery of registration requirements. This affects two categories of Ghanaian operations namely, our scientist and our traditional farmers.

It is argued that our scientists would benefit from registering their varieties. That may well be true.

However, our past experience has demonstrated that our scientific community has, with the greatest respect, not been particularly successful in marketing their discoveries. A smart foreign entity, equipped with resources, could easily overshadow our scientists in the market place, even though I appreciate that our scientific community has produced excellent plants or seed varieties. The other aspect is that the commercial nature of the process would compel our traditional farmers to “buy” the new varieties from our scientist. This would violate the main rationale of investing public funds for the research of the scientific community which has been seen as our national assistance to the farming community . They would also be constrained by the onerous obligation to buy from foreigners.

Furthermore, how would traditional farmers fare under this new regime? They cannot compete with TNCs for the protections of varieties which they have developed through their tried and tested methods of traditional farming. My colleagues have pointed out that section 21 of the Bill would protect them. Nobody can predict the extent to which our enforcement agencies can resist the aggressive salesmanship of foreign companies. Furthermore the protection given by section 21 is rather limited. It purports to protects farmers ‘ personal use of their varieties on their own holdings for the purpose of the propagation of the product of harvest which they have obtained on their own holdings. This calls for a definition of “their own holdings”. Are they debarred from large scale production of their varieties outside “their own holdings” ?

In any case, as pointed out above, they cannot use protected foreign variety or varieties developed by locals scientists without paying for them. How will such a situation be conductive to increase in productivity on their part? Farmers are likely to be priced out of the market and reduced to a landless peasantry, a phenomenon evident in other countries.

My concluding remarks have to do with the effectiveness of the proposed regulatory machinery for the new legal regime governing varieties . The experience of Ghana in regulating transfer of technology in the industrial sector makes me extremely skeptical about the prospects of an effective, transparent, objective and fair minded determination by the Registrar or other responsible authorities designated in the Act. For example, the determination of the requirements for the protection of the IP namely: “new, distinct, uniform and stable”. What assurance is there that existing variety in Ghana cannot by some slight foreign infusion be characterized as “new” and therefore entitled to protection to the exclusion of the Ghanaian breeders.

We should also be mindful of the resourcefulness and ingenuity of the Ghanaian farmers whose labours produced and sustained the cocoa industry which has remained the mainstay of Ghana’s economy. Professor George Benneh has rightly admonished us that “Technology must consult Traditions”. We should not create a situation where our indigenous knowledge in agriculture, acquired with the sweat and toil of our fore fathers is appropriated or marginalized by unscrupulous foreign operators and their Ghanaian surrogates by virtue of their dexterity in registering “new varieties”.

Since the sub-committee reports has already been sent to the speaker, I shall send a copy of my comments to the Deputy Attorney General Dr Ayine whom I had discussion on this matter.

Respectfully Submitted,

Nana S.K.B Asante

(Past President of GAAS)

Editorial
VANDANA SHIVA
Yesterday Dr Vandana Shiva, an activist for Food Sovereignty spoke in Accra about the need for countries which have come out of colonialism to protect their independence by controlling their food.

 The Insight believes that the situation in which food in Ghana is controlled by multinational corporations undermines national independence.

For us, the primary reason for growing food is to satisfy the nutritional needs of the people rather than the maximization of profit.

Where food is produced solely for maximising profit, it worsens poverty and becomes a tool in the hands of a few for perpetuating inequality and under development.

 The Insight welcomes Dr Vandana Shiva to Ghana and encourages the people of Ghana to take their destiny into their own hands by controlling their agriculture.
This is a task which must be done.

THOUGHTS OF A MYSTERIOUS MAN
With Ebow Duncan
SOMETHING DIFFERENT
I woke up this morning with a strong desire to feel, say or do something different and inspiring.

This feeling is not just about the attraction of change but a desire to escape the rottenness that has engulfed national life since that shameful day when agents of the Central Intelligence Agency of the US toppled the Nkrumah Government.

It has been the same story of acute stupidity and the worsening of the living conditions of a people who have chosen to call themselves Ghanaians.

A people who live in the past glory of an ancient great but primitive empire, of plenty gold, slaves and mud technology.

 The reality today is painted by the reggae super star Robert Nester Marley who sang the words “ in the abundance of water the fool is thirsty”.

 Ghana has all she needs to jump out of poverty and misery. Fertile lands to grow healthy food. Gold and diamond to feed the ego and line the national pocket. Rivers from which to fish and drink. Strong men and women for national protection and timber to build houses, boats and many more.

In spite of all of these the Ghanaian public sector employs only 600, 000 people out of a population of 25 million. Nobody knows how many are employed by the private sector but we know that many graduates of our universities sit at home doing nothing.

The airwaves are full of noise which they call debate. Everybody is talking but nobody is listening.

There is plenty talk about how to make the national currency strong and stop the importation of cocoyam and kontonmire.

 There are others who are shouting themselves hoarse about dum so dum so or how to generate enough electric power to power industry and bring light into our miserable lives.

Some say that the regime for the exploitation of gold could be changed to make it more profitable for the people of Ghana.

 For now Ghana gets less than five per cent of the total value of gold exported from her soil and of course the 95 per cent goes to those who have rushed on us from the colonial metropolis.

 At the very least we could manage a 50-50 deal with these godamn exploiters who have managed to turn us into hewers of wood and drawers of water.

 We can at least try to feel human again and tell ourselves that the black man too is capable of managing his own affairs.

Yesterday, it rained heavily in Accra. There were floods everywhere. One person was supposed to have died, vehicles were carried away and the politicians started their pretence all over again.

 Opposition blamed Government for the floods and Government said if only the opposition had done this and that there would be no floods in Ghana.
We are told that President Mahama will jump into one of his fanciful cars and go round Accra to inspect the flood and flood prone areas.

My goodness how different will this be from what Kufour, Rawlings and Mills did?
The same old story, same old style and no solution. Period!
What happened to the idea of harvesting to reduce the amount of water which would eventually turn into flood waters?

Why is every house being concreted to prevent the water from sipping into the ground?
Why are our gutters open to allow people to throw rubbish into them?
Why do people throw rubbish into the gutters?

Why can’t Ghana have a building code which will insist on designs of our buildings which will prevent floods?

Why can’t we change our ways to prevent the floods?
I really want to do something different today.

Perhaps engineer a revolution which will kick the ball heads in the right places and make sure that our leaders begin to think

Something new is needed and urgently too.

How Global Agri-Business Destroys Farming
By Colin Todhunter
A new review carried out by the organization GRAIN reveals that small farms produce most of the world’s food. However, they are currently squeezed onto less than a quarter of the world’s farmland. The world is fast losing farms and farmers through the concentration of land into the hands of the rich and powerful. If we do nothing to reverse this trend, the world will lose its capacity to feed itself.
This claim is based on the findings of the report, ‘Hungry for Land’ (1), which states that small farmers are often much more productive than large corporate farms. For example, if all of Kenya’s farms matched the output of its small farms, the nation’s agricultural productivity would double. In Central America, it would nearly triple. In Russia, it would be six fold.

Marina Dos Santos of the Coordination of the Brazilian Landless Movement (MST) states that the peasantry is currently being criminalised, taken to court and even made to disappear when it comes to the struggle for land. Small farmers are constantly exposed to systematic expulsion from their land, which not only affects peasants but also many other small farmers and indigenous peoples who are the target of foreign corporations. Dos Santos says that small farmers want land in order to live and to produce as these are their basic rights against land-grabbing corporations who seek only speculation and profit.

If the current processes of land concentration continue, she argues that then no matter how hard-working, efficient and productive they are, small farmers will simply not be able to carry on.

While it is often stated in official circles that the planet needs to produce more food to feed the growing population, the report suggests that more food could be produced almost immediately if small farmers had access to more land and could work in a supportive policy environment, rather than under the siege conditions they are facing today.

Elizabeth Mpofu, General Coordinator of La Via Campesina, says that the vast majority of farms in Zimbabwe belong to smallholders and their average farm size has increased as a result of the Fast Track Land Reform Programme. Small farmers in the country now produce over 90% of diverse agricultural food crops, while they only provided 60-70% of the national food before land redistribution. Mpofu says that we need to urgently put land back in the hands of small farmers and make the struggle for genuine and comprehensive agrarian reform central to the fight for better food systems.

The world is fast losing farms and farmers in many places, while big farms are getting bigger. One major reason why small farms are disappearing is the rapid growth of monoculture plantations. In the last 50 years, 140 million hectares – well more than all the farmland in China – have been taken over for soybean, oil palm, rapeseed and sugar cane alone. By definition, peasant agriculture prioritises food production for local and national markets as well as for farmers’ own families. Big agritech corporations take over scarce fertile land and prioritise commodities or export crops for profit and markets far away that cater for the needs of the affluent.

This process impoverishes local communities and brings about food insecurity (2). GRAIN’s Camila Montecinos concludes that the concentration of fertile agricultural land in fewer and fewer hands is directly related to the increasing number of people going hungry every day.

GRAIN’s report relies on statistics that show small farms are technically more productive than big farms. While industrial farms have enormous power, influence and resources, small farms almost everywhere outperform big farms in terms of productivity.

The review comes on the heels of a September 2013 report by the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (3), which also stated that farming in rich and poor nations alike should shift from monoculture towards greater varieties of crops, reduced use of fertilisers and other inputs, greater support for small-scale farmers and more locally focused production and consumption of food. More than 60 international experts contributed to the report.

The report stated that monoculture and industrial farming methods are not providing sufficient affordable food where it is needed. The system actually causes food poverty, not addresses it.

Numerous high level reports from the UN and development agencies have argued in favour of small farmers and agro-ecology, but this has not been translated into real action on the ground where peasant farmers increasingly face marginalisation and oppression.

Despite what these reports conclude and the evidence that indicates small farms have better productivity, India for example is abandoning the small farmer in favour of foreign agritech corporations. This is resulting in a forced removal of farmers from the land and the destruction of traditional communities on a massive scale. In 2008, former Finance Minister P. Chidambaram envisaged at least 600 million people from rural India eventually shifting to cities, leaving just 15% left to work the land or associated with the rural economy.

 This process is so severe, so shocking even, that environmentalist Vandana Shiva has called what is happening constitutes the biggest forced removal of people from their lands in history. According to a 2009 report commissioned by the rural development ministry and chaired by the then minister Raghuvansh Prasad Singh, in certain areas of India it also involves the biggest illegal land grab since Columbus.

The trend in India, as elsewhere, is being driven by big agritech that is working with the government to ensure a shift away from diversified agriculture that guarantees balanced local food production, the protection of people’s livelihoods and environmental sustainability. Policies that allow for the protection of local seeds and farmers’ rights to use them are paramount. Yet small farmers are being displaced and are struggling to preserve their indigenous seeds and traditional knowledge of farming systems. By patenting and monopolising seeds, big agritech is preventing farmers from saving and exchanging their own seeds that were developed over thousands of years. Agritech corporations are being allowed to shape government policy by being granted a strategic role in trade negotiations (6). They are consequently setting the policy/knowledge framework by being allowed to fund and determine the nature of research carried out in public universities and institutes .

Throughout the world, we continue to witness land grabs for non-food crops, industry or real estate interests, monocultures for export and the hijack of agriculture by big corporations backed by their co-opted scientists, media outlets and politicians (8) who continue to propagate the myth that they have the answer to global hunger and poverty. Despite mounting evidence that they do not, they continue to colonise agriculture all over the world – look no further than Africa where the Gates Foundation, Monsanto and Western governments are placing it in the hands of big agritech for private profit under the old colonialist pretext of helping the poor.

A shift from corporate-controlled, profit oriented commodity agriculture is required and involves moving towards more biodiverse organic systems that place emphasis on small farmers, local economies and food sovereignty.

Rather than addressing poverty, food inequality and hunger, big agritech corporations merely serve to perpetuate these problems and exploitative global power relations by sucking power, wealth and food from poorer countries, small farmers and local communities to satisfy themselves, their shareholders and affluent urban consumers in foreign lands. As long as petro-chemical corporate agriculture predominates and is expanded throughout the planet, the less food security and local/national food sovereignty we will see – and the more wars fuelled by oil interests, conflicts over land and water and damage to the environment we shall witness.

Restructuring of Korle-Bu the Cronyism Style
A patient receives treatment at Korle Bu
Report From An Insider
The Korle but Teaching hospital has never gone through such a horrendous path in its management throughout its 90 years of existence as it is today.

 Using a non-managerial professional, the present Board of the hospital, found it convenient to turn Mr. Ahiano, a board member, into the head of a restructuring team. Mr Ahiano, who was then residing in the USA before his appointment to the Board, does not know anything about management.

Mr. Ahiano’s restructuring ‘gimmick’ has seen the elevation of the Mrs Cynthia Boateng, one of the hospital’s BMC’s administrators as a ‘Special Assistant’ to the AG Chief Administrator (Ag CA) this position has never existed in the hospitals 90 years journey. The position was created to suit Mrs Cynthia Boateng, who failed to get the nod for the position of Director of Administration during an interview for the position.
 Presently, the position is held by one Mr Nuru-deen, another ‘guy from the states. It is unknown, that Mr. Nuru-deem used to work with Mr Eddie Annan’s defunct Masai Company.

One wonders what Mrs Cynthia Boateng’s job description is, as a Special Assistant, since the Ag CA has two abled and competent secretaries. But as if this was not enough, Mr Ahiano has created another position for Mrs Cynthia Boateng as  Deputy Director of Administration even though there is already a Deputy Director of Administration called Mr Kombian., Mrs Cynthia Boateng, is therefore holding two very key positions now- Special Assistant and a Deputy Director of Administration. In all instances, appointment to the position did not follow due process. Mrs. Boateng was handpicked by Mr. Eddie Annan to fill the positions.

Meanwhile, the cronyism style of restructuring continues unabated. The Director of Finance, Mr Annan Kakaba was relieved of his post quite recently. The position is now occupied by one Mr De-Costa Eduful, Mr Edduful worked formerly with the Accra Metro Assembly with Mrs Cynthia Boateng’s husband, Dr Boateng.

Even though he joined the hospital some two months ago, Mr. Eduful benefited from the allocation of the new cars.

Next to be sacked, was Mrs Vivian Djokoto, the Internal Auditor, her offence, was that, she queried the payment of over sixty seven thousand Ghana cedis (¢67,000) to Mr. Godfred Ahiano as allowance arrears. The position is now occupied by Mr Peadism, who used to work with the Students loan Trust, where the Ag CA Rev. A. Okpoti, is a Board member.

 Next in line was Mr Mahmound, the Director of Human Resource, who was giving the boot some three weeks ago. His crime was that, he queried Mrs Cynthia Boateng’s elevation as a deputy director without any due process being followed. It is hidden truth that the position may be occupied by Mr Ahiano or Mr Arhin, the new Deputy Director of Human Resource. Mr Arhin – another USA import also benefited for the allocation of the new cars.

Next to go is likely to be Mr. Kombian, the Deputy Director of Administration. The signs are clearly written on the wall. Firstly is the creation of another deputy director position for Mrs Cynthia Boateng. Secondly, Mr.  Kombian who had worked for eighteen years (18yrs) was not allocated any of the cars. Thirdly, there is an attempt to have him boarded medically. Interesting another attempt was made to get the hospital’s security coordinator, Capt Dodoo out of office when he was smeared with a charge of stealing 21 bags of cement in the newspapers, when that failed, an attempt was made to make his deputy, a warrant Officer, as second head of Security, proposal by Mr Ahiano, that was rejected by the Board. Not giving up, Mr Ahiano, has authorized an increment of 30% market premium to the warrant officer without course to laid down procedure.
In addition to this, a pick-up meant for the security Unit has been given to the Korle Bu police.

Where is the philosophy behind Checks and Balances here.

Ladies and gentlemen, this is all the restructuring going on at the Korle Bu Teaching  Hospital  for which Mr Ahiano has been allocated duty vehicle, a duty house and a directors pay including Board allowance.  He collects over ninety three thousand Ghana Cedis   cooly at the end of the every month.
Who is listening.                                                                                                             
DETAILS OF VAT ON BANKING
The Ghana Revenue Authority (GRA) has finally settled on the list of services that would attract the 17.5 percent Value Added Tax (VAT) and National Health Insurance Levy (NHIL).

According to a letter from the Authority to the Bankers and signed by its Commissioner-General, George Blankson, the 32 fee-based services would attract the tax from July 1, 2014.

The list of fees, commissions and similar charges for financial services that are subject to the tax was developed by the Technical Committee for the Implementation of VAT Act 2013 (Act 870) which was made up of representatives of the Ghana Bankers Association of Bankers, the Ministry of Finance and the Ghana Revenue Authority and approved by the Minister of Finance, Seth Terkper.

Find below the full list of financial services that would attract the 17.5% tax:
1. CURRENT ACCOUNTS (Foreign/Local) - CORPORATE BODIES ONLY
2. BANK DRAFT (PAYMENT ORDER)
3. STOPPED CHEQUES
RETURNED CHEQUES
COMMISSION ON TURNOVER (CORPORATE BODIES ONLY)
6. OVERDRAFT PROCESSING OR RENEWAL FEE
7. REVOL VING ACCEPTANCE CREDIT
8. ARRANGEMENT FEE FOR FACILITIES ..
9. STATEMENTS AND CERTIFICATES OF BALANCE
10. CLEARING CHARGES
11. CHEQUES FOR COLLECTION
12. STANDING ORDERS
13. TELEPHONE BANKING
14. SAFE CUSTODY
15. CHEQUE BOOKS
- Sale of cheque leaflet
- Replacement of Lost Cheque Book
16. DEBIT CARDS AND CREDIT CARDS
17. REVOLVING CREDITS
18. COLLATERAL MANAGEMENT
"
19. TRANSFER OF DOCUMENTS TO OTHER BANKS
20. GUARANTEES/ BONDS/ TENDER /PERFORMANCE
21. REQUEST FOR FOREX DRAFTS
2. OUTWARDS TRANSFER: SWIFT/TELEX
- Drafts/Money Orders - Customer
23. TRAVELLERS CHEQUES, DRAFTS
24. CHEQUE LODGEMENTS - (FOR CORPORATE BODIES AND THIRD PARTIES
ONLY)
25. EVACUATION FEE (CASH-IN-TRANSIT)
26. UNPAID STANDING ORDER
27. CLOSURE OF ACCOUNTS
28. REMOTE BANKING SERVICES
- Online Banking (Internet)
- E-statements
- E-clients
- Phone banking
- SMS banking
- Mobile Banking
- Monthly subscription
- Financial Transaction Fee
29. LENDING FEES
- Commitment Fee (Arrangement fee, Processing fee, facility fee)
- Processing Fee
- Property Valuation Fee (Open market value)
- Guarantee Commission

- Bid Security
- Bank Credit Letter (Letter of Intent)
- Mobilization Guarantee
- Retention Guarantee
- Performance Bond
- Default or restructured
30. OTHER LOANS, EXCLUDING SALARY ADVANCE
- Arrangement Fees
- New Loans
- Top-Ups
- Early Settlement Fees
31. LETTERS OF CREDIT (IMPORTS)
Establishment Commission
- Arrangement Fee
* Presentation under L/C Drawings Amendments:
- Increase in Amount
- Extension of period

- Extension of period - another quarter
.+.
- Discrepancy Other amendments:
32. DOCUMENTARY BILLS FOR COLLECTION (IMPORTS)
Handling charges - customers Negotiation Commission
- Advice of fate
"
- Bills deleted
- Protest Payment Commission
- Holding charges (per quarter)
- Prior Approval - Customers with:
- Own Resources
- Telex/Cable charges
- Swap charge
Customers allocated funds from Bank;
Exchange Telex / Cable charges
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     The Battle for Justice in Palestine
Obama’s plan: Let Netanyahu and Abbas “stew in their juices”,  Senior White House official tells Haaretz U.S. president hopes that after a few months with no negotiations and less U.S. involvement, both sides will understand it is in their interest to renew talks. 

With the peace talks being dead, what happens in Israel/Palestine?  Settlements will continue to be built, dispossession will continue against Palestinians, slowly the “apartheid” context of Israel will become more and more obvious.

While the peace talks were in process, The Battle for Justice by Ali Abunimah was published and pre-emptively indicated that the peace process is/was essentially over and done with regardless of ongoing talks.  The main context of the book is of the elements of apartheid and the associated boycott, divestment, and sanctions movement (BDS) that is sending disconcerting messages to all the pro-Israeli/anti-Palestinian two staters.  Not that a two state solution has not been possible in the past, but that it is beyond being a possibility now, leaving essentially two solutions, a single apartheid state (the considered de facto state as it is now) that is proclaimed to be Jewish, or a state with democracy inclusive of equal rights for all its citizens.

In the preface, Abunimah indicates that the Palestinians are winning – not necessarily on the ground where settlements, annexation, blockades, and military rule remains – but winning in the general knowledge of the world from the impact of the BDS movement.  The real indicator to this are the many methods and great amount of money and time that is being used to discredit the BDS movement in particular within the U.S.

Comparison
As the U.S. is Israel’s largest benefactor, the work starts with a comparison of Israel and the U.S., not the usual demographic statistics (although those are interesting as well), but a comparison based on racial considerations.  Racial profiling, discriminatory laws and courts,  and the disproportionate prison populations that result, the huge industry of security and surveillance, and the training of security forces (for “interoperability”) all play into the comparison.

The underlying basis for it is the colonial-settler mindset:  in the U.S. it is African-american/first nations subject to discrimination; in Israel it is Arabs/Palestinians facing discrimination.  A populist fear factor from this racial bias (crime, drugs, terror, religion) assists with the cowing and manipulation of the colonial-settler population.

Demographics and apartheid
Demographics is the main concern of Israel.  It is the real threat to a “Jewish and democratic state”.  Israel does not want two states as that removes part of Eretz Israel from its domain.  At the same time, a one state solution being Jewish and democratic is not possible with a resident population of Palestinians that is overtaking the Israeli population.  As argued by Abunimah, “The already present reality is a de facto binational state, albeit with apartheid conditions, throughout historic Palestine.”

Two other apartheid states are used as a comparison for Abunimah’s arguments for a one state solution that overcomes apartheid.  South Africa and Northern Ireland provide his case, the former an obvious racial apartheid state, the latter a perhaps not so obvious religious apartheid state.  The main commonalities to sustain the apartheid status are the creation of the ‘other’ as a mortal threat against a superior society, a demographic threat  (obvious in South Africa with its much larger black population), and the creation of a sense of victimhood, that the ‘other’ is the cause of the problems.

The section ends with a return to a comparison within the U.S. of economic apartheid, an awareness of the economic “Jim Crow” that exists in the U.S. and a recognition that South African apartheid was rescinded based on the accession to the Washington consensus economic agenda of neo-liberalism – in other words, the economic status quo of white control would not be interfered with.

Neoliberal Palestine
One of the more interesting parts of the discussion is that of the neoliberal economic patterns that have been imposed on Palestine, especially in the West Bank, although Gaza’s status as a large concentration camp hanging in isolation could be a forewarning of what might come to the U.S. homeland concept of neoliberalism.  Regardless of that speculation on my part, Abunimah examines what he calls Fayyad-ism.  Salam Fayyad has in the meantime resigned as Prime Minister, a position that he was not elected for (as no member of the current Palestinian governance has been elected).
As a digression from reviewing to commentary, the New York Times described Fayyad in very positive terms,
Mr. Fayyad, an American-educated economist, had gained the confidence of the West and of many Israelis, building up the credibility of the Palestinian Authority by introducing transparency, accountability and stability. Since being appointed to the premiership in 2007, he has championed law and order in the West Bank after years of chaos and focused on building the institutions of a future state.

The New York Times comment is typical neoliberal hogwash, extolling the virtues of “transparency, accountability and stability” without any sign of any of them.  And while he has “has championed law and order in the West Bank” it has been for his Israeli masters at the expense of the Palestinians people, other than the select few PA associates who manage the money.

A former World Bank economist, Fayyad was appointed by a presidential executive order in 2007 following the collapse of the Palestinian national unity government and Hamas taking control of the Gaza Strip. While he was one of the few senior politicians to frequently visit marginalised communities and ask after their concerns, tax and commodity price hikes repeatedly stoked angry street protests against him.

Palestinian unemployment has risen to almost 25% and real GDP growth is set to fall from an average of 11% in 2010-11 to just 5% in 2013, according to the World Bank.
Apart from the statistics, which coming from the World Bank are presumably rigged as most western economic statistics are rigged, Fayyad was obviously not as popular at home as he was within Israeli circles and international economic circles.

Abunimah provides a clear deconstruction of the economic miracle that was supposedly created in the West Bank.  He describes Fayyadism as “glittering illusions” from a “credit fuelled consumptive binge” that depended on foreign aid and credit plus a  repressive police state apparatus…to suppress and disarm any resistance to Israeli occupation and to crush internal Palestinian dissent and criticism with increasing ferocity.

Should these policies continue, Palestinians “can only look forward to new, more insidious forms of economic and political bondage.”

The poverty, debt, and dependence created by the neoliberal policies is discussed, highlighting the lack of employment , no real development (i.e. of a manufacturing/industrial/agricultural sense), no direct investment, easy credit  creating more debt than income, a high level of inequality, all based on a “construction and consumption binge fueled by easy credit and foreign aid [Qatar and U.S.].”

A new Palestinian settlement of Rawabi highlights the effort to “mask and normalize the worst abuses of occupation.”  Fittingly, U.S. style mortgages are considered a “soft power tool” for “explicitly political goals” that “advances U.S. foreign policy.”  The economic plans demonstrate a “close integration between the aid and NGO industries…and the advance of neoliberal economics and U.S. hegemony” using policies formulated with the PA elites “behind closed doors with no transparency or democratic process.”

Normal Neoliberalism?
Another aspect of economic normalization (recall that “normalization” was a major part of the reason for the first Intifada) in its current status is allowing Israeli companies to operate in the West Bank, “almost all of which are complicit in Israel’s occupation, apartheid, and denial of fundamental human rights.”

It is a form of Shock Doctrine as described by Naomi Klein, wherein a powerful ruling alliance between a few large corporations and a class of wealthy politicians..facilitated by brutal force, a usurpation of democratic rules and torture…a silent partner in the global free market crusades.”

Two final constructs of neoliberalism are presented.  First is the destruction of the economic infrastructure (among other structures) of Gaza, forcing it into a literal underground economy now highly constricted by the new neoliberal order within the Egyptian junta.  Secondly, the creation of industrial zones and free market zones serves as a means of controlling and then annexing more and more Palestinian territory.
All this is done for the benefit of large corporations (beyond the obvious benefits to Israel).  These zones create areas where Israel and corporations “operate in exploitive ways forbidden in their home territories.”  It is time, argues Abunimah, to
abandon the illusion that the formal recognition of a Bantustan-like Palestinian state alongside Israel would do anything to free Palestinians from an exploitative economic system that is already deeply entrenched.

As a final note on the never say die neoliberal order, the U.S. has plans to continue with their neoliberal shock doctrine if the two sides start negotiations anew,
In addition, the White House is pleased both with the plan drawn up by General John Allen, which proposes security arrangements for a two-state reality, and with the plan to restore and upgrade the Palestinian economy – devised by the U.S. administration, the quartet envoy Tony Blair and private sector representatives. These two plans “can be put back in the mix if the parties are willing to come back to the table seriously,” the official said.

I defer to the reader’s intelligence and the above comments when considering that perspective.

BDS
It was the South African BDS movement that finally caused the country to make a volte face and get rid of its political apartheid structures, unfortunately replacing them with economic apartheid.  Israel is facing a burgeoning movement that borrows heavily from that success, adapting it as necessary for the slightly different situations.

This is where Abunimah sees the win, the growing awareness of Israeli actions brought about by the BDS movement, and ironically, Israel’s attempts to discredit it.  Israel realized early that it could not argue “the facts” against the BDS as it was the very facts on the ground that provided the support for the campaign.  They have also realized that trying to argue the victim role has had little effect again in consideration of these very facts.  Instead Israel has changed to ideological arguments that attempt to deny the validity of the people supporting BDS and to hasbara, a public relations efforts to disseminate abroad positive information.

Israel sees the BDS movement as “deligitimization”, another “existential threat” that is coalescing with the one state solution by “undermining moral legitimacy…constraining military activities, destroying Israel’s image.”  To counter this they have used a variety of tactics in various situations.

Much of it has to do with rebranding.  This includes ‘pinkwashing’ attempting to present Israel as a liberal haven for the LGBT community.  It also includes ‘greenwashing’, a “propaganda campaign of smoke and mirrors to conceal some of Israel’s most troubling, environmentally destructive and criminal activities, many directly linked to military occupation and colonization.”

One of the largest areas of countering BDS is within the universities of the U.S., the “David Project”.  This program targets teachers and students, it attempts to intimidate institutions, misuses civil rights laws, and attempts to criminalize campus behaviours.  A relatively long comparison is made between these actions and the U.S./Arizona actions with Hispanics, including walls along the Mexican border and the ‘other’ described as ‘terrorists’.

Success?
As per Israeli sources, the negative view of Israel is increasing, in a “finding that indicates that public opinion is sharply out of step with official government policy.”  No surprise there. Netanyahu has indicated the “its not about the facts, its about the defamation of Israel,” that it is an “image problem.”  Again very similar to U.S foreign policy.

The Reut Institute, “a nonpartisan and nonprofit policy think tank in Tel Aviv designed to provide real-time, long-term strategic decision-support to Israel,”  “tacitly conceded that resistance to Israel is based on genuine and justifiable grievances and the denial of Palestinian rights.”

In essence, BDS has shifted the focus of debate from that of Israeli victimhood and the virtues of neoliberal democracy to that of the voice of the Palestinian people.
The end of the two state solution’s endless negotiations and the increasing awareness created by the BDS movement highlight problems brought about by Israel onto itself.
The Battle for Justice in Palestine is a well referenced, well written, and well argued presentation on the current state of affairs in Palestine.  It is a strong update to events within that particular sector of global ideological manipulations.

Cracking the US Economic Blockade of Cuba
The powerful regional organisations created in Latin America, an important legacy of the late Hugo Chavez, have forced cracks in Washington’s 50- year economic blockade of Cuba. Senior US regime figures have called on President Barack Obama to loosen the blockade.

Obama loosened a few of the additional measures imposed by Bush the Second (lifting some severe restrictions on family member visits) but has mostly maintained the status quo of travel bans on US citizens, ‘trading with the enemy’ sanctions and imposing large fines on companies (with over 10% US shareholding) which trade with Cuba.
  The US economic, commercial, and financial blockade (called an ‘embargo’ in the US) has tried to isolate and lay siege to Cuba since the early years of the revolution. The first version was signed into force by President John F Kennedy, just after he ordered a personal supply of 1,000 fine Cuban cigars.

However, now that Cuba has taken on a leading role in continental organisations such as the CELAC, Washington insiders have been forced to admit that it is the USA (‘America’) that has become ‘increasingly isolated’ in the Americas.

The late Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez and his political mentor, former Cuban President Fidel Castro, in the early 2000s, led the movement against a proposed ‘Free Trade Area of the Americas’ (FTAA) and against the Washington-dominated Organization of American States (OAS). Venezuela and Cuba created the left-bloc ALBA (the Bolivarian Alliance for Our Americas) as a counter to the FTAA. In 2005, at a summit in Argentina, Chavez held a shovel to demonstrate that he had come to ‘bury’ the FTAA; and indeed he did.

 Then in 2008, backed by others including President Lula of Brazil and President Kirchner of Argentina, Chavez led the creation of UNASUR, a South American bloc that has since helped defuse Washington’s destabilisation plans in several countries.

The unification process peaked a little more than year before Chavez died of cancer.  In Caracas, in December 2011, 33 Latin American and Caribbean heads of government confirmed the creation of CELAC (the Community of Latin American and Caribbean States). The only countries of the Americas left out were the USA and Canada.  With a population twice the size of the US, CELAC has become a new counter-weight to the Washington-based OAS. This new bloc moved immediately to build new direct relations, for example with the European Union.

We should see this recent letter to Obama on Cuba, from 50 US establishment figures, in this wider context. Titled ‘Open letter to President Obama: support civil society in Cuba’ (http://www.supportcubancivilsociety.org/), it calls for relaxation of travel to Cuba by US citizens, increased support for Cuban civil society, ‘principled engagement in areas of mutual interest’ and some relaxation of financial restrictions for ‘authorised’ relations.

This is a very long way from the liberal ideas of free movement and free trade, so often preached by Washington. But while the letter’s proposals are quite modest, and there is a traditional destabilisation agenda, it is the authors that make a difference. There have been many similar proposals from what we might call US ‘official dissidents’, former officials who have disagreed with the bipartisan US policy on Cuba.

This time the proposal comes from figures still deeply embedded in the US security, finance and diplomatic oligarchy. Notably there is John Negroponte, mastermind of death squads (under the Reagan and Bush 2 administrations) in Central America and Iraq, along with several military and business figures and recent heads of the US mission in Havana (called an ‘Office of Interests’, as there is no US Embassy).

The letter admits that US policy on Cuba (embedded in both US law and Presidential decree) has left Washington ‘increasingly isolated’ in the Americas. That policy is unpopular in the US and even more unpopular in Florida, where the anti-Cuban mafia have their main base. An Atlantic Council poll (February 2014) said that 56% of US people and 63% of Florida residents were in favour of a change in US policy towards Cuba.

Nevertheless, given the bizarre, elite politics of the US Congress (a Republican dominated Lower House has just voted to impose sanctions on Venezuela, because of violence initiated in that country by US client groups), the letter recognises that the legislative form of the policy (set in two laws passed under the Clinton administration in the 1990s) cannot be quickly changed. However they suggest Obama can act to make some important changes by presidential decree.

In the imperious language of Washington these changes are said to ‘serve as catalysts for meaningful change in Cuba’; in practice they signal a fear of being left out of a Cuban development process which is slowly but steadily engaging a range of other countries.
The week after the letter was published a high level delegation headed by Thomas J. Donohue, the President of the US Chamber of Commerce, paid a visit to Havana. Their main interest seemed to be in reviewing the economic reforms underway, over the past few years.

Cuba’s ‘updating’ of its economic model (in the Cuban view this is a subset, and not the defining feature, of Cuban socialism) has included changes to the 1995 foreign investment law, which selectively attracts capital to joint ventures in identified priority areas. These areas have been tourism, mining, oil and energy, the health sector, light engineering and infrastructure. Key partners so far have been Venezuela, China, Spain, Canada, Brazil and Russia.

The letter to Obama from 50 US figures proposes an expansion of ‘licensed travel’ for a range of US citizens (professionals, business people, NGOs, academics), including authorising the use of ‘pre-paid’ credit cards. Presently, the US Treasury has to license US citizens and residents to travel to and spend money in Cuba. Non-US citizens are generally not affected by these laws, unless they try to use US-linked banks and credit cards.

Second, the group proposes that Obama authorise finance, scholarship and communications links between ‘civil society’ groups in the two countries. This has been contentious on the Cuban side because the US has for some years used ‘civil society’ groups in attempts at political destabilisation. The Sumate group in Venezuela was one such group. Its former leader Maria Corina Machado, now a leading opposition politician, was recently implicated in a plot to assassinate President Nicolas Maduro. In Cuba US citizen Alan Gross remains in jail for smuggling satellite communications equipment, with which he was trying to set up a US-mentored political network. Similarly, a USAID project to start an alternative twitter network (Zunzuneo) was recently exposed.

  Third, the letter proposes priority for ‘principled engagement in areas of mutual interest’. This is important because issues such as migration, drug control, environmental management and counter-terrorism have all failed because of the poor relations, rooted in the US refusal of diplomatic relations. The failure was best illustrated by the outcome of Cuba’s sharing of intelligence, in the late 1990s, on planned bombings of Cuban tourist hotels. Instead of moving against the Florida-based terrorists, the FBI traced back and arrested some of the sources of that intelligence, five Cuba agents now known as the Cuban Five. Three of these men are still in US jails, political prisoners for more than 15 years, simply because they tried to warn of terrorist attacks planned against their country. Securing their freedom will be at the forefront of any such ‘mutual interest’ dealings.

Finally the US group asks for financial liberalisation to allow all US-authorised activities. This is also important, as the blockade has made many simple, day-to-day transactions difficult.

 A US president can authorise the use of certain forms of credit, but the Congress would have to change the legal basis of wider sanctions, and these have been aimed at bigger targets, in recent years. US citizens are still banned from buying Cuban cigars, for example, but there have been very few fines for such infractions since about 2008. The US Treasury (through its OFAC agency) has shifted its focus to finance companies, resulting in some big fines.

For example, under these anti-Cuban laws the Dutch travel company Carlson Wagonlit Travel was fined nearly $6 million and Despegar, an Argentine travel firm, was fined $2.8m, this year. Back in 2009 the ANZ Bank was fined $5.7m while Credit Suisse was fined $536m, the largest ever US sanctions penalty. These fines underline the point that US laws continue to affect even foreign companies, if they have 10% or more US-based shares.

The US economic blockade of Cuba is truly a dinosaur policy. It is rejected at the UN every year by almost every nation on earth, it is rejected by the US people and it is now rejected by Washington insiders, who have finally discovered that is it they who are isolated. Whether the Obama administration moves on this or not, it is clear that Latin American unity has been the recent driving force for change.
 

Pope must walk the talk


Pope Francis, Head of the Catholic Church

By Kevin Barrett
Pope Francis stunned the world by stopping his motorcade next to Israel's apartheid wall.

He got out, laid his head on the wall, and prayed. Visible behind him was graffiti reading "Pope, we need someone to speak about justice", "Free Palestine," and a comparison of Palestine to the Warsaw ghetto.

The iconic photo of the Pope's Palestinian prayer went viral around the world. Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu was furious – but vowed "not to get mad, but to get even." One wonders what sort of revenge Netanyahu is plotting.

The Pope's gesture spoke louder than his mostly empty words. He was obviously praying for the apartheid wall to come down. But he cannot say such things directly. The Zionists have more than enough financial and media power (and enough professional killers and dirty tricks experts) to "get even" with any Pope who speaks out against them too forcefully and directly.

The Pope's historic prayer at the apartheid wall illustrates the rise of religion as a force for social justice. Prior to 1979, social justice struggles were associated with "the left," meaning socialism or communism. Both movements were dominated by atheists and secularists. They saw religion as a tool of oppression, an "opiate of the people."

In 1979, two epochal events signaled a sea change in modern history. In Iran, the Islamic Revolution overthrew a corrupt and brutal secularist dictatorship and established a new social model – one that sought social justice through a religiously-based society. And in Poland, the Catholic Solidarity labor movement arose to challenge atheistic Communism. Soon religious Afghans were challenging the atheist Soviet occupation of their country. In 1989, the Berlin Wall came tumbling down...and with it the "Godless Communism" of the Soviet Empire.

Since then, the Islamic awakening has been challenging secular capitalism in many parts of the world. The Catholic Church has begun to take a strong stand against materialistic values. Russia's President Putin is turning Russia into a pro-religious society – a 180-degree turn from the Communist era of brutal atheist dictatorship. And with his support for Eastern Ukraine and Syria, President Putin is wrecking the New World Order's plan to wipe out traditional religions and establish a one-world secularist dictatorship.

In Turkey, pro-Islam forces have gradually gained the upper hand over the kemalist atheists, who had conducted one of the worst cultural genocides in world history during their doomed attempt to wipe out Islam. The long struggle of Turkish Muslims to regain their country has also been a struggle for democracy, human rights, and social justice.
The rise of Hezbollah and Hamas, both religiously-based resistance movements against Israeli occupation, is another sign of the times. The Palestinian resistance is no longer led by the secularist PLO, which has become a tame guardian of the status quo. Today the most successful anti-Zionist resistance group is Hezbollah, which defeated Israel in the war of 2006, and which is prepared to inflict an even more stunning defeat on the Zionists should they dare to attack Lebanon again.

Will Putin, the Pope, and the pro-justice Muslims (led by the Islamic Republic of Iran) unite to put an end to Zionism and its dream of a New World Order with a capital in Occupied Jerusalem?

Catholic historian E. Michael Jones foresees such an eventuality. In February 2013, Jones and I were returning to Tehran from a meeting with religious scholars in Qom. Jones, who admires Iran's God-centered society, expressed the fervent hope that the Pope would come to Iran to make common cause with the Islamic Republic – and turn decisively against Zionism. "But could this Pope (Ratzinger) ever do such a thing?" we asked. "He won't be Pope forever!" Jones announced.

An hour or so later, regular programming was interrupted by a special bulletin: "Pope Resigns!" It was the first time in 600 years that a Pope had decided to step down. If E. Michael Jones is ever nominated for sainthood, I will happily testify to his miraculous powers of premonition.

The new Pope, Francis, seems blessed with a heartfelt concern for ordinary people. He appears genuinely pained by the suffering of the Palestinians under Israeli oppression. And he seems instinctively opposed to the heartless power of New World Order bankster capitalism.

Will Pope Francis soon be "Going to Tehran"? Will he announce that Netanyahu needs an exorcism, and Zionism needs a funeral? Will he stand with Putin against NATO's nuclear encirclement of Russia? Will he join the world's Muslim scholars calling for an end to usury and the destruction of the current international banking system in favor of something more humane and equitable? Will he demand that the US radically scale back its obscene military spending and lead the planet towards demilitarization...and the transfer of trillions of wasted military dollars into schools, hospitals, mass transit, and sustainable energy? Might he call for an end to biological technologies that threaten human dignity and even human existence – such as bio-weapons, designer genes, and trans-humanism?

None of these things are possible today. But could they be possible tomorrow?
If the new religious movements for social justice unite – and make common cause with everyone who supports justice, including those who consider themselves secularists – who knows what the future might bring.

Editorial                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       
June 4
Once again Mr Jerry John Rawlings and his friends have celebrated the anniversary of the coup which saved him from facing the firing squad for subversion of the state of Ghana.

We understand why this celebration must be important for Mr Rawlings, his family and friends. After all if it were not for the mutiny of June 4, he would not be alive.
 In the same vein we can imagine what the families and friends of the victims of June 4 feel when the event is celebrated in the manner in which it has been thrown into our faces.

What will the children of Real Admiral Amedume feel, when they are reminded about the fact that their father was shot at the stake for legally and legitimately taking a loan, the equivalent of Gh¢ 5.00 (Five Ghana Cedis) today?

What about all those whose livelihoods were destroyed forever and have continued to suffer humiliation since 1979?

In any case, which of the Ghanaian leaders will survive if they are judged by the standards of the so-called  June 4 uprising.

The noise about June 4 can sometimes be very annoying especially as Ghana is perhaps in a worse state than what it was in 1979.

 Please spare us the ugly noises about June 4.

Renowned Israeli Economist Predicts Economic Catastrophe for Israel
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Nyetanyahu
By Richard Silverstein
            They say that economics is “the dismal science.”  Frankly, I never excelled in math or science in school.  That was my brother’s field and he ended up a university chemist.  But over the past decades, economics has become a crucial element in understanding societies, wealth and national politics.  That holds doubly true in the case of Israel and Palestine.

          As with everything concerning this subject, there is a propaganda “line” that Israel-advocates sell the world.  First, there was the pioneer nation that made the desert bloom, turning it into a modern society.  Lately, it’s become the “start-up nation.”  This myth sells an Israel full of technical geniuses coding their hearts out to bring innovation to the world.  It suggests an Israel in tune with the democratic and entrepreneurial spirit of the rest of the world.  Even a nation on the cutting edge of technological discovery.  After all, if Warren Buffett invested $4-billion in one of  Israel’s most profitable companies, doesn’t that prove the case?

While there is an element of truth to this story, as there are with all myths, it conceals far more than it reveals.  A recent interview with renowned Israeli economist Dan Ben-David, exposes the rest of the sordid picture of an economy rent in two, divided between haves and have-nots, between a secular Jewish elite and all the rest.  It’s worth quoting extensively from this piece since Ben-David offers a probing, even revelatory portrait of a nation, and economy in dire straits.  It’s a picture you’ll almost never see in the mainstream media:

Professor Dan Ben-David, a noted economist, has been observing Israel’s socioeconomic policies and studying their long-term implications with consternation for more than two decades. Over the last six years, serving as the executive director of the Taub Center for Social Policy Studies in Israel, his insight by which the Zionist project could ”end in tears” has been deepening. He feels that ”the window of opportunity enabling us to save the state from collapse is getting smaller, as we reach the point of no return.”

In an interview with Al-Monitor, Ben-David explains why the path that the State of Israel is following in its 66th year will eventually lead to the system’s collapse.
Keep in mind, this isn’t Norman Finkelstein or Noam Chomsky speaking.  This is a respected Israeli economist who buys into the Zionist dream, albeit with a critical perspective.  When he declares Israel is on the road to ruin, someone ought to sit up and take notice.

Here’s more of his analysis:
When I deal with the socioeconomic aspect of Israel, I have the feeling that we’re letting the country slip through our fingers. It’s ironic. On the one hand, this really is the “startup nation.” We are on the forefront of developments in high-tech and medicine. At the same time, however, there is another country here. What we have, in effect, is two countries. We track productivity rates in Israel, and based on the data, productivity here is among the lowest in the developed world. Obviously, that has implications on growth and quality of life. All the OECD [Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development] states beat us in that.

It is important to understand that this is a trend. It is a process that began in the 1970s, so it is possible to say that we have been in decline for the past 40 years. If, in the 1950s and 1960s, we were able to reduce the gaps between us and the world’s leading countries, the trend has reversed itself since then.

That means that even when there are people who live here and who want to live here, there will also be people who leave because they can get more somewhere else. We are passing the threshold in which more and more people will not want to live here, and that could end in tears. We have to ask ourselves where our children and grandchildren will be. It is true that we are not talking about major calamities in the next year or two. We still have time to make changes and fix the problems, but that time is running out.

The other aspect of the problem is inequality and poverty. Poverty rates in Israel are among the highest in the developed world. Of course, these two things are interconnected. If, in the 1950s and 1960s, we were an example to the West of how a country does things the right way, we have since become one of the least egalitarian countries in the world.
Behind the inequality and low productivity, we find a growing population that did not receive the tools it needed from the state to integrate into the modern workforce. By this, I mostly mean the Arab and ultra-Orthodox sectors. Their situation has a negative impact on productivity. In an economy where productivity is low, it is impossible for wages to be high. When productivity in an entire country is very, very low, it says something about that country’s ability to offer high wages. The population that continues to grow lacks the tools and condition to integrate into the market. What is needed to understand the reasons for this is to take a look at the level of the country’s education in the core subjects. Since the 1990s, the State of Israel’s achievements in international mathematics and reading tests are among the lowest in the developed world, and we can’t seem to overcome that.

…This is true even if we don’t include the ultra-Orthodox, because their children do not participate in international testing. In other words, if they were included in the test results, the situation here would be even more dismal. When we look at the achievements of Arab children, we see that the level of education we provide them in core subjects is beneath what they would get in developing countries. That has enormous implications, because if we consider the demographics, we see that almost half the children in this country are either ultra-Orthodox or Arab. When they will grow older, they will increase the percentage of the population that is unable to participate in the workforce. Productivity will then decrease and existing gaps will expand. It is the responsibility of the state to reach these children and provide them with the tools they need.

First of all, we need a structural reform in the education system. If the education we provide in the periphery is at least as good as the education in the center of the country, and if we connect those places to the center of the country with a rapid, inexpensive, reliable and readily available transportation system, it will mean that almost the entire population will be living within half an hour of the country’s center. That’s a key issue, and it’s hard for people to swallow that.

The main story is that there are gaps among us, among the part of the country that is not ultra-Orthodox or Arab. If we just look at the middle class, we find that the gap between its two extremes is among the highest in the Western world. Gaps in education hint at what will happen once children grow up, because all of this will be expressed later on as gaps in income.

That is actually incorrect [the the Netanyahu government is a major instigator of structural reforms]. We’re riding a wave of marketing. Not every wage agreement is a reform. We are avoiding any dealing with the core problems. We, the Israelis, believe that everything will work itself out. Apparently, it’s part of our nature. There have been some changes in the past decade, and it is all starting to click for quite a few people, but what is happening now is that we are treating the symptoms without treating the actual problems.

What is needed here is systematic treatment of the problems of the kind that the prime minister must lead, together with his Cabinet. What is needed is a comprehensive master plan, because we are in a race against time…And as hard as it is now, once we reach a certain point it will become absolutely impossible to do anything. We will reach the point of no return.

It won’t happen in two years. I’m talking about trends. Take the ultra-Orthodox, for example. They make up 8.5-9% of the total population. What will happen when their children grow up? We won’t be able to manage. That is why we have to reach their school-age children today. There isn’t much time left. Half of those children don’t even get a developing world education, so there is no way that they can maintain a developed world economy. They could only maintain a developing world economy, and a developing world economy can’t maintain a developed world military. At that point, there will be no country left. This is a whole new definition of national security: If we don’t have an economy that can keep everything together, we will not be able to contend with the security challenges we face.

When it comes to the ultra-Orthodox, the main emphasis should be on educating their children. There is no modern country apart from Israel that allows parents to prevent their children from receiving the education they need. There are things that every child must know.

Ben-David expounds upon his ideas in greater detail in this report published by his Taub Center at Tel Aviv University.

Shir Hever, one of Israel’s foremost economists studying the costs of Occupation and maintenance of the national security state, and a former student of Ben David’s, adds his own analysis:

…[Ben-David] doesn’t ask himself why Israel has such a faulty education system…Massive and decade-long cuts in Israel’s education system have been the direct result of unsustainable security costs…Deep discrimination within Israel’s education system has channeled resources to the illegal colonies, drying up the center. Israel’s national education system is geared towards preparing the pupils for the army, a highly militaristic system, in which Arabic, if learnt at all, is mainly seen as a tool to enter into service in a military intelligence unit. In fact, there are entire schools which are sponsored by weapons manufacturing companies.

Ben David has previously shown shocking numbers of educated Israelis who leave Israel, seeking employment elsewhere. Of course, many of those who leave do so because they hope to give their children better education somewhere else, but what about those who wish to raise their children in a less militarized environment?
What Mazal Mualem refers to as the “diplomatic process,” is a code-name for a system of colonization and aparheid. This system was accepted by the majority of the Jewish-Israeli public because it promised to discriminate in their favor, but as Ben-David shows, the discrimination and inequality tends to seep further, and has caused wide gaps even within the hegemonic group.

Also, this article didn’t really talk about what is exactly Israel’s “start-up nation.” The real question is how many of the successful companies which contribute to this image are in fact security and military companies, whose success depends on the continuation of the repression of Palestinians. Such companies are reluctant to hire Palestinian citizens of Israel, and usually ultra-Orthodox Jews as well (unless they happened to have served in the army). Therefore, the issue of occupation and apartheid is not one aspect of this story, but the very root of the problems which Ben-David so aptly describes.

In the past, Israel’s advocates here have claimed that Israel’s economic divisions are somehow not the fault of the State since the have-nots in the Palestinian and ultra-Orthodox sectors opt out of the national educational and social system.  This is simply not an excuse.  As Ben David points out, the responsibility of a government and society is to the good of the whole.  If the greater good includes educating all children so that they may support themselves and their families and contribute to society, then government must both offer a good education for all and obligate parents to participate in the educational system.  There is simply no excuse for accepting half the nation’s children getting no or substandard educational opportunity.  A society that settles for this is one that has failed, despite whatever innovation it may offer in other areas.  Israel is not a nation only of the secular educated elite.  It is a nation of all its citizens (or should be).  If it is any less, it is a failure.  Plain and simple.

Though Shir alludes here to the enormous costs of maintaining Occupation and the national security state, this article elaborates on the issue.

America’s Role in the Creation of the State of Israel
US President Hussein Obama
By Karin Brothers
Weir’s fascinating history focuses on how the State of Israel came into existence through a cynical using of the United States and how it was defended from American critics who saw the support for Israel as violating US principles and damaging US interests.

The significance of the 1917 Balfour Declaration, the British “gentleman’s agreement” between the British government and Lord Rothschild that pledged British support for a Jewish homeland, has not been understood by many for the quid pro quo that it represented.  The agreement, which occurred when it appeared that Germany was winning WW I, was that Zionists would work to get the United States involved in the war if Britain would deliver Palestine as a Jewish homeland.  The reason for the American involvement in the war and the American contribution to the arrangement have not been widely understood: the Balfour Declaration (as well as the later British Mandate) were drafted in both Britain and the US, including by U.S. Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis.

Germany had no inkling of this deal until the post-war 1919 Paris Peace Conference, which Zionists attended to ensure that Britain would come through with its part of the agreement.

Even before Britain washed its hands of Palestine, Zionists recognized that they needed the support of the United States for Israel to survive and thrive, so the U.S. became the focus of propaganda and political pressure.  Harry Truman, the US President who recognized the State of Israel immediately after it declared itself a state, had received a then-staggering $2 million from a Zionist donor during what had appeared to be a losing presidential campaign.  State Department leaders were against supporting Israel because it damaged U.S. relations with Arab countries and, more importantly, violated important American principles of self-determination and justice. Elected leaders, vulnerable to political pressure and access to campaign funding, were not able to maintain such America-first integrity.

Weir documented various little-known Zionist efforts to support the creation of their state.  The activities — basically bribes, lies, subterfuge, threats and violence– included:
 Zionist leaders’ “mixed reaction” to Nazism, with some seeing that the convergent goals would benefit a Jewish state that required a Jewish population;

 Secret American Zionist clubs (including the elite Parushim with Felix Frankfurter) which pledged to work for Israel behind the scenes;
Creating the myth that a refuge was needed for Jews (including falsifying anti-Semitism in Germany and Poland and, more importantly, sabotaging western countries’ efforts to open their doors to Jewish refugees after WW II in order to ensure that Jews had few choices of refuge outside of Israel); and
 Zionists’ role in the creation of Christian Zionism and the Scofield Reference Bible.
Weir ends her short history of Israel’s creation by documenting some key examples of how Israel-firsters were able to destroy the careers — if not the lives — of prominent Americans in government, journalism and academia who warned of the loss of American credibility in supporting a state that was based on religious discrimination.

Weir keeps her book focused on the early history of Israel, ignoring highly significant later events, particularly those concerning Senator William Fulbright: his uncovering of Jewish charity fraud that recycled charitable donations into US propaganda, his attempts, with JFK, to force the main Zionist organization to register as an agent of a foreign government and the loss of Fulbright’s Senate seat to the then-unheard of Dale Bumpers.

The main messages from Weir’s history are that the Jewish community has not legitimately needed a homeland- refuge from anti-Semitism and that Americans must take back their country by insisting that their elected officials place the interests of the United States before those of Israel.

The United States throws Libya into turmoil and runs away…
By Dr. Michael J.K. Bokor
Folks, I have heard it said several times that the US has interests but no permanent friend anywhere in the world. Certainly, it has demonstrated its military prowess in many parts of the world top confirm such an impression and to worsen it in other cases.

Happenings in Libya provide ample evidence to suggest that the US is running away from the very shadow that it created and used to insert itself in the Libyan crisis.
After putting Libya in a state of turmoil after helping opponents of Muammar Gaddafi to kill him and destabilize the country, the United States is detaching itself from that country. The nasty events in Benghazi that resulted in the killing of its Ambassador Stephens notwithstanding, the US seems to be sitting on the fence as the situation in Libya deteriorates by the day.

Can you believe it that the US is now asking its citizens to leave Libya (as the situation deteriorates further and the government cannot put its house in order to rule the country)?

Here is the news: “US tells its citizens to leave Libya amid unrest”, according to the BBC.
“The US State Department has warned any American citizens in Libya to leave the country immediately. It said the situation in the country remained unpredictable and unstable. On Tuesday, the US said it was sending a warship carrying around 1,000 marines to the region for any possible evacuation of American officials.” (See: http://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-27599301)

MY COMMENTS
One would have expected the US to be directly involved in repairing Libya, and that its allies in the multinational force (Britain, France, Qatar, etc.) that collaborated with it in devastating Libya would not turn tail but support the Gaddafi haters to rebuild their country and ensure that the democracy that they dangled in front of them would be accepted and installed to move Libya forward.

Unfortunately, nothing of the sort is happening, which leaves Libya in a worse situation than it was under Gaddafi (no matter how much venom his leadership style had wrought in his own citizens and outsiders alike). Destroying the country’s infrastructure and system of administration was no problem; but rebuilding that infrastructure and ensuring that Libya re-emerges from the ashes of Gaddafi is the problem that none of the outside forces wants to contribute toward solving.

Is the US teaching a lesson in failed military aggression against a sovereign state that nobody will be willing to learn?

If you heard President Obama’s speech today at the US Military Academy at West Point, New York, you should be left scratching your head:

He promised a new US foreign policy based on “collective action” with allies abroad, saying that the US would still lead but would avoid the “costly mistakes” of the past. He told graduates at the Academy.

He announced a $5bn (£3bn) fund to fight global terror and promised the US “must not create more enemies than we take off the battlefield”. (See: http://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-27606536)

Call it an epiphanic moment, and you will be right. And now that their own trained spy (Edward Snowden) is revealing all he can about their intelligence activities in cyberspace, they are more than scared. John Kerry is asking Snowden to “man up” and return home if he believes in the US’ justice system. (See: http://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-27614001)
The boomerang effect is hitting hard; not so? There you are, Uncle Sam!!
I shall return…
E-mail: mjbokor@yahoo.com

Subject: Still I rise: Maya Angelou
Maya Angelou
You may write me down in history
With your bitter, twisted lies,
You may tread me in the very dirt
But still, like dust, I'll rise.

Does my sassiness upset you?
Why are you beset with gloom?
'Cause I walk like I've got oil wells
Pumping in my living room.

Just like moons and like suns,
With the certainty of tides,
Just like hopes springing high,
Still I'll rise.

Did you want to see me broken?
Bowed head and lowered eyes?
Shoulders falling down like teardrops.
Weakened by my soulful cries.

Does my haughtiness offend you?
Don't you take it awful hard
'Cause I laugh like I've got gold mines
Diggin' in my own back yard.

You may shoot me with your words,
You may cut me with your eyes,
You may kill me with your hatefulness,
But still, like air, I'll rise.

Does my sexiness upset you?
Does it come as a surprise
That I dance like I've got diamonds
At the meeting of my thighs?

Out of the huts of history's shame
I rise
Up from a past that's rooted in pain
I rise
I'm a black ocean, leaping and wide,
Welling and swelling I bear in the tide.
Leaving behind nights of terror and fear
I rise
Into a daybreak that's wondrously clear
I rise
Bringing the gifts that my ancestors gave,
I am the dream and the hope of the slave.
I rise
I rise
I rise.
Maya Angelou